Actress/Film: Maggie Gyllenhaal, Secretary (2002)

Cheating On/With: Wimpy office boy Peter (Jeremy Davies), whom she briefly agrees to marry; with deliriously creepy power-tripper and spanking enthusiast E. Edward Grey (James Spader, again).

Alright, We Forgive You: Erotic in precisely the slightly-uncomfortable-but-sort-of-endearingly-comic way director Steven Shainberg sets out to achieve.

It's also quite touching to see the meek and nervy Holloway discover a wild side through her sub/dom relationship with Grey. Plus...well, look at the DVD cover. Yep.