Russell Crowe - American Gangster (2007)
Going For: Noo Yawk
Actually Is: An Aussie who’s been punched in the throat by an angry ninja.
If Richie Roberts were dead, he'd roll in his grave and put his corpse fingers in his corpse ears everytime Crowe, who plays his fictional self, opens his trap. He isn't dead though, but he's got to be a bit miffed.
Crowe, sex-object of women the world over as Maximus in Gladiator, plays Roberts as an unlikeable, overweight bad father who can't catch a break let alone Denzel's Frank Lucas.
Hope when "totalfilm.com: the movie" is made, we aren't as unlikeable and amnesiac of accent.
Phonetic Phrasing: "Fraank Luucus is abave tha mafier" (1:07 in the trailer) Typical of Crowe's dialogue, it starts off Brooklyn, ends up Brisbane.
Other Offenses: Body of Lies (Southern American) The Quick and The Dead (Southern American) 3:10 to Yuma (Southern American)
Keanu Reeves - Youngblood (1986)
Going For: French-Canadian
Actually Is: A Californian with a bollock caught in his zipper.
Canoe's first film, this should have served as an orange alert for all casting agents looking for leading men with a flexible linguistic pallet.
Not only did world cinema ignore this kick-in-the-balls to the less than testicularly secure French Canadians, they wholly embraced it as a genius debut and went on to put him in every role requiring an English accent for the rest of the decade.
Phonetic Phrasing: "That maan, iz fuckeng an animaaal" (0:04 in the clip) They're laughing at you Canoe, not with you.
Other Offenses: Dangerous Liasons (RP), Much Ado About Nothing (RP), Dracula (RP), The Devil’s Advocate (Southern American)
Comments
Rusty4bears
Jul 16th 2009, 12:04
What? No Robert Englund in 'The Adventures of Ford Fairlane'?? "Ello Ello Ello" Or Brion James in 'Tango & Cash' "Yoo wankah"
Alert a moderator
padrigo
Jul 16th 2009, 12:30
What about Heath Ledger in Ned Kelly- worst Irish accent ever. Even worse than Tom Cruise in Far and Away.
Alert a moderator
KittyFantastico
Jul 16th 2009, 12:35
How the hell did Keanu Reeves' accent in Bram Stoker's Dracula not make it in there? It's horrendous!
Alert a moderator
imaginarium
Jul 16th 2009, 12:42
Orlando Bloom in Ned Kelly...
Alert a moderator
dgoodswen
Jul 16th 2009, 12:51
If you read carefully, Keanu Reeves' accent from Bram Stoker's Dracula IS on the list, just his appearance in Youngblood predates it - don't worry, we're calling out his entire repertoire of accents!
Alert a moderator
Agent69
Jul 16th 2009, 13:25
Please do one with 15 best accents.
Alert a moderator
PadmanForever
Jul 16th 2009, 17:28
Sam Worthington was definitely a little shaky during pent up moments of T4 - Marcus suddenly became Australian. Russell Crowe syndrome. Hmm, best accents, now that would be a tricky'un. I was impressed at Johnny Depp's consistent (if not 100% authentic) handling of the Scottish accent in Finding Neverland. I'm half Scottish and I can't even manage a full sentence. Also, Christian Bale's usual non-accented American becomes pretty impressive when you hear his bizarre 'cockney in a blender with an Italian mafioso' speaking voice.
Alert a moderator
dgoodswen
Jul 16th 2009, 18:37
Sam Worthington was definitely on the shortlist for his T4 shenanigans, the only reason he didn't make the cut was because he has no past form - if his accent is as wobbly in Avatar as it was in Terminator Savlon then we'll fully reconsider...
Alert a moderator
ashley.russell
Jul 16th 2009, 18:38
I'm guessing TF have never seen a little period film called Basil starring Jared Leto and Christian Slater, both of them are horrendous and yet so so unintentionally funny
Alert a moderator
ashley.russell
Jul 16th 2009, 18:38
I'm guessing TF have never seen a little period film called Basil starring Jared Leto and Christian Slater, both of them are horrendous and yet so so unintentionally funny
Alert a moderator
Comex
Jul 16th 2009, 19:45
OK, OK...I can agree with most of the accents you have on this list, but do you really think that Gerard Butler was trying for any sort of Greek accent in "300"? I didn't hear that at all. And since when is a weird lisp the same as a Greek accent? Everyone in the movie was being a bit melodramatic (har-har) but that's not the same as affecting an accent.
Alert a moderator
AYBGerrardo
Jul 16th 2009, 21:05
Sean Connery "Other Offenses: The Hunt For Red October (American)" Eh? Definitely worthy of a place on the list, but he was meant to be Russian. Funny that he learnt the language but couldn't drop his accent.
Alert a moderator
AYBGerrardo
Jul 16th 2009, 21:08
Sean Connery "Other Offenses: The Hunt For Red October (American)" Eh? Definitely worthy of a place on the list, but he was meant to be Russian. Funny that he learnt the language but couldn't drop his accent.
Alert a moderator
jdean888
Jul 17th 2009, 14:44
Brad Pitt in The Devil's Own was a laughable Northern Irish accent. Gerard Butler's P.S. I Love You attempt at Irish was pretty funny too, when he kept calling Hilary Swank 'Hahllee'.
Alert a moderator
Desperation
Jul 17th 2009, 17:21
Natalie Portman in V for Vendetta?
Alert a moderator
joeymac
Jul 17th 2009, 17:34
Don Cheadle single-handedly prevented Ocean's Eleven from being a 5* film.
Alert a moderator
welshdragon42
Jul 17th 2009, 18:25
what no one has failed to mention so far is the amazingly diverse and odd range of (cough) interesting accents that we inflicted upon us in Beowulf, with complete inconsistency and weirdness from Ray Winstons cockney (no modification attempted) to a variety of English, American, and most importantly the bizzare and inconsistent oldy english/scandinavian/failing accent of John Malchovich! How can no one have noticed this (or maybe the men were oggling too much at the animated Angelina Jolie or freaked out by the muscled Ray Winston lookalike?)
Alert a moderator
sirdday
Jul 18th 2009, 5:38
Meryl Streeps accent is spot on. aussies actually sound that bad. spot on meryl
Alert a moderator
Bluey3
Jul 18th 2009, 16:09
Thank you so much for mentioning Tom Cruise [& Nicole Kidman] in Far & Away - this film has long been one of my all-time turkeys for the reasons you've given :-) Other dishonourable mentions ought [IMO] to go to would-be Oirish maidens Meg Ryan [Restoration] and Cameron Diaz [Gangs of New York]. Weren't there any Irish actresses available? On the same principle, I won't get started on Bridget Jones....
Alert a moderator
Bluey3
Jul 18th 2009, 16:14
As someone has already mentioned Keanu Reeves... thought I'd add a note about his performance in Dangerous Liaisons aka Bill & Ted visit the 18th Century. Like, duuuude...
Alert a moderator
apple
Jul 20th 2009, 23:48
marion cotillard in Public Enemies:she's radiant but her US accent is too bad every Brad Pitt accent:he's not good in accents Robert Downey Jr in "Sherlock Holmes" trailer:is Holmes an american guy?
Alert a moderator
PadmanForever
Jul 21st 2009, 1:23
If you listen to the "Watson, what have you done?" line at the end of the Holmes trailer, there is definitely an accent there, but it would seem overall that Downey Jr is using the "softly softly" approach to accent work, which though it sometimes makes it seem like you're not trying, can be better than just walking about going (in this case) "Corr blimey, I'm from Lahndan taan". We'll see how it goes in the full film. Anyways, the reason I returned to this article was to ask something kind of along the lines of that "gentle accent" approach -- I saw a little bit of "Days of Thunder" tonight, and I can't remember - is Nicole Kidman even supposed to be trying not to be Australian? Because if she is, it certainly doesn't show.
Alert a moderator
Jason Voorhees
Sep 3rd 2009, 0:12
Richard Gere in The Jackal is worse than anything, Keanu Reeves in Bram Stokers Dracula, Harrison Ford in K19 the widowmaker.
Alert a moderator
Gunner1
Nov 4th 2009, 8:31
Clearly not a lot of South Africans commenting on this list, otherwise we'd have heard about Val Kilmer's utterly atrocious Cape Town accent in 'The Saint' - not to mention every single bloke who was supposed to be a South African in Lethal Weapon 2!! (and what's worse is that I believe Joss Ackland was born in SA, and yet his version of an SA accent was awful!!) On the other hand, what I've heard of Leo DiCaprio and Tim Robbins' accents in the trailers (haven't seen the films yet) of 'Blood Diamond' and 'Catch a Fire' were much closer to spot on!!
Alert a moderator
sunnyrandall
Jan 18th 2010, 15:48
Gotta agree with Gunner1: Hands down, worst South African accent ever - Val Kilmer in The Saint - Oh, the horror, the horror.
Alert a moderator
micdog2001
Jan 21st 2010, 1:54
It's funny, I'm from the San Francisco Bay Area and don't know much about accents and such and i will assume you are correct BUT I usually like all the films that these actors are in. Reeves, Costner, Connery, Crowe, it seems I don't even notice when they are bad.
Alert a moderator
kmcryer
Feb 1st 2010, 15:53
Yes, many of these are really bad, but I can't believe you forgot these two: - The classic! Dick Van Dyke doing a cockney accent in "Mary Poppins." That alone should have taught Hollywood what a bad idea it was to hire American actors for British roles. - Ewan McGregor as a Southerner in "Big Fish." It was like his version of what a Confederate general may have sounded like. I swear to God that my ears were bleeding!
Alert a moderator
KerrAvon
Mar 8th 2010, 22:10
Ewan MacGregor as Alec Guinness in the prequels, s**te!
Alert a moderator
hlglazier
Apr 8th 2010, 23:42
Natalie portman in v for vendetta - worst british accent ive heard its almost insulting dick van dyke in mary poppins audrey in my fair lady brad pitt in inglorious basterds - what the hell was he trying?
Alert a moderator