Case for: Pride & Prejudice, Pirates Of The Caribbean: The Curse Of The Black Pearl

Against: The Hole, Domino, King Arthur, Love Actually

Sexiest moment: The Domino strip. Hilariously midjudged, but oddly dirty.

Acting-est moment: Choking to death on her own vomit in The Hole.

Verdict: Pretty good. While the court has yet to see hard evidence of her cultivating a wider range, she’s moved away from Pirates power-totty into thespier territory (Silk, Atonement, The Best Time Of Our Lives). And she is not a bounty hunter...