P.S. I Love You (2007)
The Film: Recovering from the death of her husband, Gerry (Gerard Butler), Holly (Hillary Swank) receives ten letters he wrote before he died, designed to help her move on with her life.
Why So Serious? Holly and Gerry are a happily married couple… until Gerry get a brain tumour and dies.
She collapses and withdraws from friends and family, until her 30th birthday, when she receives her first message from her dead husband.
The messages, which all end with ‘PS I Love You”, send Holly on different adventures, telling her to celebrate herself and not to be consumed with sadness.
Her friends and family worry that the messages are causing her to hang on to the past, but with each message, she grows stronger and discovers more about herself, and how to carry on living without him.
Will It Make You Cry? You’ll cry when he dies, you’ll cry every time she gets a message from him, you’ll cry when it end happily for her.
You’ll also cry when you hear Gerry’s awful Oirish accent.
Will It Uplift You? Unless you’re suffering from the death of a spouse, probably not.
Cynicism Score: 5 – The feminists might have an issue with the fact that without her husband’s guidance, she’s a complete mess.
Next: Autumn In New York
Comments
TheTingler
Jun 24th 2009, 10:31
I think Jude wins the prize for sheer "life-is-s***-and-people-are-worse"-ness. Requiem For A Dream at least has the get-out clause of "drugs are bad" to fall back on. Most of the rest are just normal soap operas. Some excellent metaphors in there by the way TF!
Alert a moderator
ChroniC2805
Jun 24th 2009, 10:50
What about bridge to terabithia or marley and me both of those films had me crying like a baby
Alert a moderator
ashley.russell
Jun 24th 2009, 11:24
Changeling should definitely be in there, its nothing but police corruption, dead children, missing children, scary fraudulent children, a mental hospital and a serial killer
Alert a moderator
durden
Jun 24th 2009, 11:26
well,i wouldn't call them miserable but the only films that made me cry were dead poets society and october sky...don't think any of the above have done that...
Alert a moderator
fluffulike
Jun 24th 2009, 11:41
I never really got over bambi's mum dying! Only movie I ever really cried in.
Alert a moderator
Lindz28
Jun 24th 2009, 13:50
In the valley of Elah is the most depressing film I've seen. Tommy Lee jones and Susan Sarandon's son dies. Then their other son goes missing. He's found not just dead, but brutally stabbed, burnt and chopped up into little bits. Its like the ending for Million Dollar baby but for the WHOLE film :(
Alert a moderator
BennettsVest
Jun 24th 2009, 15:03
The Deer Hunter isn't exactly a shining beacon of cheer. I think my mate summed it up best when he said "That was superb, but I never want to see it again." Then he shot himself.
Alert a moderator
thefilmguru
Jun 24th 2009, 16:15
I am sorry but youve missed a biggy with The Elephant Man - i mean that film is so depressing he gets abused nearly the whole film. Scenes with that security guard never fail to be depressing with how he is. It ends on a sort of high in that hes content, but really - it is still DEATH. The Elephant Man has to be in there.
Alert a moderator
pazozo
Jun 24th 2009, 17:04
is Jude entirely based on Jude the Obscure? It's on my reading list for English for 'Love through the ages' but if it's anything like the film I think I'll give it a skip
Alert a moderator
tachikoma83
Jun 24th 2009, 17:55
Where is "Grave of the Fireflies"? that film almost killed me.
Alert a moderator
magicwings
Jun 24th 2009, 18:10
Two words: The, and Wrestler.
Alert a moderator
Sonic
Jun 24th 2009, 22:51
THANKS FOR THE SPOILER WARNING FOR SOPHIES CHOICE YOU STUPID CUNTS!
Alert a moderator
indran
Jun 25th 2009, 0:40
I'm putting in my vote for The Cook, The Thief, His Wife And Her Lover and Martyrs as two of the most horrifyingly downbeat films ever made. Really stay with you after watching them. And of course Requiem For A Dream. You just can't feel good watching that.
Alert a moderator
imaginarium
Jun 25th 2009, 14:25
Brokeback Mountain. Love that can never be properly fulfilled, they can never be together, they have their biggest argument, spilling all the frustration and regret, right before one of them dies, alone, for the very reason they couldn't be together.
Alert a moderator
Catchphrase
Jun 26th 2009, 13:47
You missed Boys Don't Cry.
Alert a moderator
obi500
Jun 26th 2009, 14:40
I know a lot of people may not have seen it but studio Ghibli's Grave of the Fireflies is the only film thats made me cry.
Alert a moderator
xotitanicox
Jun 27th 2009, 18:21
What Moulin Rouge? I cry every time I watch it.
Alert a moderator
WileyWasabi
Jun 27th 2009, 21:18
How could you leave off My Life??? The movie starring Michael Keaton and Nicole Kidman, couple trying to get pregnant, and when she does they find out he has terminal cancer, so he makes a bunch of videos for their unborn son, because it is expected he'll not live to see him born. Total sobfest.
Alert a moderator
VictoriaRusso
Jul 17th 2009, 22:40
I guess the author made differences between movies that made people cry and depressing movies. So totally agree on Requiem for a dream, great art piece after which it's quite hard not to suicide. Another thing is Bamby, just because it's kinda made for kids, but awfully depressing! And of course Brasil. There's nothing worse than a happy ending that never really happened.
Alert a moderator
apbgreen
Aug 4th 2009, 16:21
'Million Dollar Baby'. A film so relentlessly depressing that swallowing your own tongue seems somehow comforting.
Alert a moderator
Apathygrrl
Aug 6th 2009, 12:00
Totally agree with Requiem. One of the most bleak movies I have ever seen. I'd just like to mention The Green Mile & The Mist. Both are so painfully depressing that I can't ever watch them again.
Alert a moderator
MrSmith70
Nov 17th 2009, 22:17
yeah i agree, requiem for a dream is such an excellent film but the unconfortabiliity of watch it is extreme...... harrowing at the mind with sara's hallucination, felt like getting sick. churning of the stomach with harry's decomposing arm 'pre-op', felt like getting sick. aronofsky's best.......
Alert a moderator
CatBear
Aug 15th 2011, 17:24
I'm pretty sure that when you wrote depressing, you meant s**t? Other than Requiem it's more like a list of the worst, soap-opera like films of all time. How about some good, but depressing films; My Life Without Me, The Laramie Project, Mean Creek...
Alert a moderator
erikmartin
Dec 13th 2012, 19:28
"Synecdoche, New York" should be in the list. That one emptied out my soul even more than Requiem For A Dream.
Alert a moderator