15. Southland Tales (Richard Kelly, 2007)
What they said:
“Frustrating and finally rather pointless. Is there anything going on behind these randomly firing synapses?”
Xan Brooks, The Guardian
What we say:
The same critics who applauded Kelly’s freaky teen time-travel debut Donnie Darko for its snippy sense of humour and impenetrable plot somehow missed the point of its super-ambitious follow-up.
Southland Tales throws away in seconds ideas other movies would snaffle up as high concepts, whipping up a tornado of fascism, pornography, subjectivity and The Rock’s eyebrow.
It’s flawed, certainly, but almost better for it – think of it as an American Brazil. And rewatch immediately.
Comments
red157
Mar 3rd 2009, 13:54
I agree with a number of your choices whether they be left-field (Reign of Fire... hell even Van Helsing) or films I didn't particularly consider underrated (Fear or Loathing, Jackie Brown). That said, some of them are just terrible.
Alert a moderator
red157
Mar 3rd 2009, 15:12
Ah this wasn't chosen by TF. I see...
Alert a moderator
scousegit
Mar 4th 2009, 1:59
Fear and Loathing is superb... i read the book AFTER watching the film and had johnny depp's voice in my head the whole time which has to be a great compliment. However, Eyes Wide Shut as an underrated and REWARDING film? Blimey... there's some twisted people out there, yourselves included, TF
Alert a moderator
gwilkie31
Mar 5th 2009, 13:33
The Mist has one of the worst endings I have ever scene. Completely out of place. So, you would rather shoot all you family in the face, making each one watch, than wait it out, search for fuel, cannabilise Granny or whatever? You care for the characters throughout the film and then, at the climax, they give you the middle finger. Bah!
Alert a moderator
fortunesfool
Mar 6th 2009, 13:03
Where's Exorcist 3? It's a damn sight better than Jingle all the way! Big up for Strange Days though, vastly under rated movie.
Alert a moderator
walkabout
Mar 6th 2009, 15:00
Going by all the grief it got at the time, I would have expected Waterworld to appear here. Glad it isn't, I though it was great!!!
Alert a moderator
senlac
Mar 6th 2009, 15:28
I'd like a poll for the 20 most overrated movies!
Alert a moderator
bluntmann
Mar 6th 2009, 17:16
I get the appeal of the other 19 but personally Eyes Wide Shut was almost three hours of my life I'd rather spend banging my head against a wall than watch again
Alert a moderator
avoidz
Mar 8th 2009, 13:31
Superman III deserves more credit than it's given. The set-pieces you mentioned are awesome. The drunk Supes and subsequent junkyard fight are absolute classics of cinema.
Alert a moderator
avoidz
Mar 8th 2009, 13:34
Agreed. This is Tarantino's masterpiece, under-appreciated by most audiences. Easily more enjoyable on subsequent viewings than Pulp Fiction, this is a terrific movie.
Alert a moderator
nathanman
Mar 8th 2009, 20:01
Glad Reign Of Fire got a mention here! Cracking film that never really reveived the praise it was due! Also, Strange Days, one of the best films of the last century!
Alert a moderator
scabo33
Mar 9th 2009, 17:00
i dont think the mist and jackie brown were under rated.... jus under appreciated
Alert a moderator
BooBoo1981
Mar 10th 2009, 18:00
I think the movie that nobody even knows about, weirdly, is True Romance (QT's one romantic masterpiece). Sooooo underrated for sure.
Alert a moderator
jgreene02
Mar 10th 2009, 21:04
I'm glad somebody realizes how underrated Silent Hill is. It's easily the best video-game adaption yet. I know that's no saying much, but it's miles ahead of the competition
Alert a moderator
Mrmotion
Mar 15th 2009, 21:50
Some of these I can totally agree with- but Cast Away? A more self indulgent Tom Hanks fest Ive yet to see!
Alert a moderator
hstemp
Mar 18th 2009, 22:57
erm, where the hell is Howard the Duck in this list????!
Alert a moderator
MattyVanHorn
Apr 9th 2009, 15:34
I would add a few more: "Waking Life" and "A Scanner Darkly" - Mr. Linklater's roto-scoped deep thinkers. Intelligence and curiosity are increasingly rare in film, but these two are both gleeful brain-twisters. Add "Sunshine" as one of the most artful, interesting and well-acted sci-fi films of the last decade. I can't recommend this film enough. And a sad last lament to "Serenity", paean to the criminally-canceled sci-fi/western/morality play series. Has any recent sci-fi film deserved a franchise more than this one? (Saw 5...really?)
Alert a moderator
ubcool
Apr 10th 2009, 18:48
sorry but excluding the mist , jackie brown and jingle all the rest really are bad. i vote alien 3, exorcist 3, tranformers animated movie, navy seals, planet terror, escape from la, screamers, captain ron
Alert a moderator
leontheiguana
Apr 22nd 2009, 20:09
I agree with some of these (Jackie Brown is a masterpiece) but really... Van Helsing? It's not the Mashup thats bad - it's the script (Wit? Seriously?), the performances, the final fight, the bad pacing, the shlocky special effects... I think maybe you're trying to defend a guilty party.
Alert a moderator
thekillingjoke
May 23rd 2009, 23:11
I too agree with most. But I can't say I agree with Van Helsing. As for the rest Eyes Wide Shut is phenomenal. Jackie Brown is by far the best QT. However I do think that Southland Tales is more of a guilty pleasure than actually a good film.
Alert a moderator
MikeyRix
May 29th 2009, 20:28
"Maybe even his [Tarantino's] last great film..." Excuse me? "Kill Bill: Volume 1", anyone?
Alert a moderator
Smokinator
Jan 3rd 2010, 13:35
the mist is one of my fav films and th ending made me cry, but apart from that review you had on the page i would say its not underrated, because most other critics love it, but i would say it is underseen- meaning that a lot of ppl do not know about it.... like MOON
Alert a moderator
stevolbauer
Jul 2nd 2010, 15:34
I agree with many of these choices, Reign of Fire was seriously underrated and I dont know why, its class. Blades of Glory is actually really funny. But Jackie Brown is not QTs best film, while it is brilliant, Pulp, Dogs, Kill Bill and Basterds are all better.
Alert a moderator
TinEar85
Jun 19th 2011, 2:56
Wow, for a movie site, you people have terrible taste in movies.
Alert a moderator
TinEar85
Jun 19th 2011, 3:08
Duh, I just read the rest of the headline. Damn ADD. I guess I should be blaming the voters not the website.
Alert a moderator
darkstarr71
Jul 15th 2011, 13:55
EYES WIDE SHUT just misses out on being the last great Kubrick movie for one important reason; it is set in the wrong time. If it had been filmed as a period piece, this would have been a masterful send-off for a truly great director. The original Arthur Schnitzler short story "Traumnovelle" was written in 1926, and had Kubrick set the story in this time period, the social and moral conventions of the time would have made sense of the characters attitudes, outlooks and responses to events in the film. Having chosen to set it in the New York of 1999, we find the characters unbelievably shocked by thoughts of marital infidelity, prostitution, issues of familial pimping and orgies. I mean, a masked orgy in a locked mansion house, with no real shocking scenes of carnal indulgence? Set in 1999 it generated yawns and confusion, whereas within the societal conventions and strict class structures of 1926, the “shock-horror” reactions of the characters make a heck of a lot more sense. So re-watch and mentally CG in a 1920’s milieu and you have yourself a fitting period end to an illustrious career. Oh, and for the record, VAN HELSING is irredeemably bad and cack-handed on every level, and stands as the only film I’ve ever come close to walking out on in disgust. Only the entry fee of nearly £10 made me stay to the shoddy, gruelling finish. Eeuuuuggghhh…!!!
Alert a moderator
darkstarr71
Jul 15th 2011, 13:57
g*****n - where's my LINE BREAKS??????!!!!!!!
Alert a moderator
darkstarr71
Jul 15th 2011, 13:59
Gosh darn it....where's my g*****n?????!!!!!!!!!!!!
Alert a moderator
darkstarr71
Jul 15th 2011, 13:59
Gosh darn it....where's my g*****n?????!!!!!!!!!!!! I've been PG rated
Alert a moderator
darkstarr71
Jul 15th 2011, 13:59
Gosh darn it....where's my g*****n?????!!!!!!!!!!!! I've been PG rated!
Alert a moderator
Igrayne
Jul 30th 2011, 14:32
True Romance is not a Tarantino film, you can tell because it is not c**p. Not that Tony Scott is much better but he does not p**s me off with over the top quirks and ripping films off under the excuse they are "homages".
Alert a moderator
FBNReichart
Feb 5th 2012, 12:01
Silent Hill is clearly over your head if you think it has no plot READ http://www.gamefaqs.com/ps/198641-silent-hill/faqs/4180
Alert a moderator
alanupu
Jul 7th 2012, 12:59
Cast Away I did not realize it was a movie I was under the impression it was a long advert for Fedex. Product placement gone mad that alone is enough to warrant not including the movie in this list let alone the basketball
Alert a moderator
rustbearcleaver
Aug 30th 2012, 18:14
I would say the most underated movie is Gran Torino. A classic in my mind...
Alert a moderator