The Orphanage is good but does drag a bit at points (just a wee bit though). Garden State is infernal. Natalie Portman has never been more annoying and him off Scrubs should not make another film (unless it's got the janitor in it too). I'm leaning to K19-The Widowmaker, but that's just because I've not seen it either and I've heard it's decent.
Good idea for a thread too.