A lot less cheese than New Moon…

The Twilight Saga: Eclipse review

The Twilight Saga: Eclipse review: Twi-hards and dragged-along-boyfriends, rejoice! After the ponderous, dreary New Moon, The Twilight Saga has rediscovered its bite with a flick that ups the action, sex, pace and humour and ditches the constipated moping, flat gloss and atrocious CGI. Yay!

For the uninitiated: In Twilight, mortal klutz Bella (Kristen Stewart) fell for teen exsanguinator Edward (Robert Pattinson) and they pissed off a bad vamp, Victoria, by killing her mate.

In New Moon Edward dumped Bella, causing two cinematic hours of sulking and flirting with werewolf Jacob (Taylor Lautner) before the lovers were reunited when Ed dabbled with suicide by sunlight.

And now Eclipse, where Victoria (Bryce Dallas Howard, taking over from sacked Rachelle Lefevre) creates a neck-draining army to kill Bella and Edward, forcing the werewolf and vampire clans to team up for battle. And where Bella has some serious decisions to make…

Does she want an eternal, blood-lust life with the literally frigid Edward? Or a human existence with clothes-shirking, eager pup Jacob? And can she get Ed to swap gentle nuzzling for getting down and dirty?

Taking over from New Moon’s Chris Weitz, David Slade knows exactly what fans want and gives it to them. But this is the guy who brought us Hard Candy, so nothing’s going to go down without added edge.

Squeal-inducing close ups of real-life hook-ups Pattinson and Stewart kissing? Yes. Mooning over Lautner’s abs and pecs without acknowledging the inherent comedy in it? No.

Though he honours Stephenie Meyers’ beloved world, Slade recognises that solely pleasing an ardent fan base does not a great movie make.

Along with Melissa Rosenberg’s sassed-up script, he breaks the navel-gazing Bella POV approach to trace the story away from Forks and expand the action to more cinematic proportions.

He cracks the whip on dialogue delivery (no more the lip-biting, pause-filled painful chats), ensures tongue is in cheek for the more bromidic moments (“I’m hotter than you,” declares Lautner with a twinkle in his eye) and introduces a new vampire effect that makes the bloodsucker battle a T-1000-esque, genuinely involving affair.

Bella is feistier, the CGI wolves are better and there’s more  Billy Burke bringing welcome world-weary humour. And, girls, the ‘leg lift’ is everything you’ve ever dreamed of. It’s hot.

But like its predecessor, it’s too long, the wolves are not quite good enough to fully convince and there’s some distractingly bad wig action going on.

Lautner merely channels Tom Cruise (poorly) in lieu of acting and some of Slade’s group shots look disquietingly like marketing standees or action figures (maybe that’s the snarky point?).

Though it’s certainly an improved experience for the non-devotee, Eclipse still isn’t likely to pull off what Weitz also failed to do – winning new fans of the saga.


Not as good as Twilight, not as bad as New Moon, Eclipse is decent teen cinema that will thrill fans and mollify their accompaniers. Can’t wait for the caesarean-by- teeth in the next one…

Film Details

User Reviews

    • EmmaPendlebury

      Jul 4th 2010, 20:49


      Saw it today. It's much better than New Moon and I'd say on a par with Twilight. You can't take this franchise seriously with it's over-dramatic pauses and sighing from the actors but as a blockbuster Eclipse is an enjoyable few hours.

      Alert a moderator

    • umafan1

      Jul 9th 2010, 15:51


      A lot better than the first movie. Great plot, great pacing [not a boring 2 hours like twilight 1], great characters. It all worked so perfectly and it was as if the makers of the first movie realised where they had gone wrong and made a much better film. Very good. I enjoyed it a lot more than I expected to.

      Alert a moderator

    • hulk68

      Jul 18th 2010, 13:59


      I am usually generous in my ratings. However,after reading the review and user comments I feel I have seen a different movie than the one reviewed above. This movie is difinately the worst in the series. Much more action and better pacing? Have you ever watched a half hearted action movie before? I don't think so. Me and my brother nearly slept most of the movie time. Except few good scenes (actually 3)It is so boring and lazy, the actors take ages to say the words that we already know. This could work on TV but as amovie it is more of a torture exprience. Bad, bad and bad avoid.

      Alert a moderator

    • hulk68

      Jul 21st 2010, 12:29

      I wish respected users write something instead just giving a rubbish movie five stars just to adjust the user rating

      Alert a moderator

    • hulk68

      Jul 21st 2010, 12:32

      And the genre is mentioned as Horror! Our neighbourhood cat is scarier than this movie.

      Alert a moderator

    • superfurryliam

      Jul 22nd 2010, 13:42


      A definite improvement on the first two installments, David Slade's direction has undoubtedly made some shots beautiful that would flop in someone else's hands. Overall, I still find the pace a little slow for these films when they are advertised like adrenaline-pumping action films! Still, the action sequences were handled better and the acting a slight improvement (R-Patz even has a few funny one-liners). Overall, a big improvement on New Moon and grander than Twilight. Enjoyable and entertaining...

      Alert a moderator

    • madrox

      Aug 2nd 2010, 13:51


      Alert a moderator

    • krister

      Oct 28th 2010, 4:49

      As louis vuitton loafers louis vuitton sandals Salsa has become more popular louis vuitton bikini so has the louis vuitton scarf need for the gucci t shirt dance wear that gucci boots for women is needed men gucci shoes when gucci womens shoes you dance. Shoes are louis vuitton shoes louis vuitton flats one of the most gucci shoes high tops important parts gucci scarf of dance wear for the gucci jeans dancer. Dance shoes gucci sunglasses differ cheap gucci shoes from regular in gucci mens loafers many ways. louis vuitton shirts First regular gucci shoes gucci outlet shoes are louis vuitton sunglasses designed louis vuitton slippers to look attractive gucci shoes for men as its first priority, louis vuitton jeans and then they are made to be as comfortable as possible. Of course, compromises have to be made. The most beautiful shoes are certainly not necessarily comfortable if not uncomfortable and they will not be made for high impact activities.

      Alert a moderator

    • cataclysmcdkey

      Dec 4th 2010, 6:14


      cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm wow cd key wow cd key cataclysm collector's edition cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm buy wow cataclysm wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm cd key wow cd key cataclysm collector's edition cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm buy cataclysm key cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm key wow cd key cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm

      Alert a moderator

    • tomic

      Dec 16th 2010, 8:29


      ed hardy Jeans ed hardy hats reebok easytone reebok easytonereebok easytone shoes Reebok easy tone ed hardy Purses ugg classic cardy nfl jerseys nfl jersey nfl jerseys classic tall uggs ugg boots NFL Jersey Moncler jackets canada goose cheap ugg boots new era hats wholesale wholesale new era hats mlb trade rumors mlb trade rumors reebok hockey reebok hockey skechers designs skechers designs ghd ghd hair straighteners ghd hair ghd styler ghd straighteners ghd mk4 Shape Up Shoes Cheap Shape Up Shoes shape ups skechers GHD Hair Straighteners GHD Hair Straighteners canada goose new era hats wholesale nfl jerseys wholesale adidas shoes cheap adidas shoes wholesale new era hats canada goose canada mlb jerseys mlb jersey outlet moncler replica handbags wholesale spaccio moncler ugg boots wholesale GHD Hair Styler GHD Hair Styler moncler shop new era hats wholesale ugg boots uk wholesale new era hats ugg boots on sale mbt shoes mbt shoes jordan shoes wholesale mbt mbt abercrombie fitch wholesale discount mbt shoes mbt shoes cheap MLB Jersey MLB Jersey

      Alert a moderator

    • jordansshoes

      Feb 22nd 2011, 9:01

      Abundance is a life cheap nike jordan on sale style, a way of living your life. It isnt something jordan shoes eleven you buy now and then or pull down from the official nike jordan shoes cupboard, dust off and use once or twice, and then air jordans 1 return to the cupboard.Abundance is a philosophy; it appears in your air jordans six rings physiology, your value system, and carries its own jordan retro eights set of beliefs. You walk with it, sleep with it, bath with it, feel buy jordan elevens with it, and need to maintain and take care of it as well.Abundance doesnt always men orginialjordan retro elevens require money. Many people live with all that jordan retro elevens money can buy yet live empty inside. Abundance begins inside with some air jordan 13 main self-ingredients, like love, care, kindness and gentleness, thoughtfulness and jordan retro 14 compassion. Abundance is a state of being. It radiates air jordan 4 outward. It shines like the sun among the many moons in the nike jordans world.Being from the brightness of abundance doesnt allow the new air jordans darkness to appear or be in the path unless a choice to allow authentic nike air jordan shoes it to. The true state of abundance doesnt have men's air jordan on sale room for lies or games normally played. The jordan shoes clearance space is too full of abundance. This may be a challenge because we still need to jordan on sale free shipping shine for other to see. HYD

      Alert a moderator

    • gm0nk3y

      Feb 23rd 2011, 4:03

      purple wallet purple wallet mini washer dryer mini washer dryer cheap floor lamps cheap floor lamps how to get pregnant fast how to get pregnant fast white writing desk white writing desk black couch black couch purple lamp purple lamp tube top tube top pink chairs pink chairs white tank top white tank top

      Alert a moderator

    • triston31

      Mar 9th 2011, 17:05

      I love this movie. Had the whole unrequited love down perfect. Great review btw. directv texas

      Alert a moderator

Most Popular