I Saw The Devil


Little sympathy for Mr Vengeance…

I Saw The Devil review

Revenge is a dish served repetitively in Kim Jee-woon’s baroque, bludgeoning thriller. Whether it’s best served that way is another matter.

A keen stylist and genre-hound, Kim aced ghosts in A Tale Of Two Sisters and cowboys in The Good, The Bad, The Weird. But his gory entry into South Korea’s avenger sub-genre – following Park Chan-wook’s sick-pics – puts savagery before substance.

Initially, the cast reel us in. Emphasising Park parallels, Oldboy’s Choi Min-sik is indelibly feral as Kyung-chul, a school bus driver who kills women.

Unluckily for him, his latest victim’s fiancé is top cop Soohyeon (the pretty but intense Byung-hun), who isn’t satisfied by catching Kyung-chul: instead torturing him, releasing him, tracking him by GPS then torturing him again in a sickening game of cat-and-mouse.

Making scant sense plot-wise, its filmic function lies in giving Kim carte blanche to max the mayhem: cue bashed bollocks, mashed heads and lashed tendons. Strong stomachs are required, though Kim’s fluent direction aims for art over exploitation.

A greenhouse dust-up is ferocious yet lush; a knife fight is contained yet explosive. Bursts of black wit are judiciously dished, as when a doctor advises a busted-up Kyung-chul to play football more gently.

But as pain gets administered, the payback seems insufficient, with Kim resorting to desperate tonal lurches. Subtextual blows, mainly ‘revenge corrupts’, land like afterthoughts.

Granted, a film this well-made won’t bore. But as the blood thickens and the plot thins, our sympathies finally revert to the woman who implores Soo-hyeon: “This is meaningless. Please stop it.”


Half engrossing, half just gross, Kim’s revenge epic is all form over content. The style dazzles, but just think what he could do with a decent script.

Film Details

User Reviews

    • timberlandsale

      Apr 29th 2011, 7:59

      All of us have read timberland clearance thrilling stories in which the hero had only a limited and specified time to live. Sometimes it was as long as a year, sometimes as short as 24 hours. But always we were interested in discovering mens timberland boots just how the doomed hero chose to spend his last days or his last hours. I speak, of course, of free men who have a choice, not condemned criminals whose sphere of womens timberland boots activities is strictly delimited. Such stories set us thinking, wondering what we should do under similar circumstances. What events, what experiences, what associations should we crowd into those last hours as mortal timberland 3 eyes boat beings? What happiness should we find in reviewing the past, what regrets? Sometimes I have thought it would be an excellent rule to live each day as cheap timberland boots if we should die tomorrow. Such an attitude would emphasize sharply the values of life. We should live each day with a gentleness, a vigor, and a keenness of appreciation which are often lost when time stretches before us in the constant panorama of timberland 6 inch boots more days and months and years to come. There are those, of course, who would adopt the Epicurean motto of “Eat, timberland chukka boots, and be merry,“ but most people would be chastened by the certainty of impending death. In stories the doomed hero is usually saved at the last minute by some stroke of fortune, but almost timberland dancing boots always his sense of values is changed. he becomes more appreciative of the meaning of life and its permanent timberland boots spiritual values. It has often been noted that those who live, or have lived, in the shadow of death bring a mellow sweetness to everything they do. Most of us, however, take life for granted. We know that timberland roll top boots one day we must die, but usually we picture that day as far in the future. When we are in buoyant health, death is all but unimaginable. We seldom think of it. The days stretch timberland work boots out in an endless vista. HYD timberland boots clearance timberland boot timberland boat shoes

      Alert a moderator

Most Popular