Reviews

Red Cliff

4

John Woo reloads…

Violent, vast, hard on the arse, Red Cliff yanks John Woo back from the career precipice of 2003’s Paycheck, the last (and least) of his Hollywood forays.

The Asian auteur’s first native venture in over a decade and a half, it’s no cap-in-hand homecoming; rather, the priciest Chinese-language picture ever, tackling an oft-retold (novels, comics, videogames) chunk of military history.

Amping the pressure further, Woo wades into an arena thronged with super-sized, CGI-assisted spat-taculars, from Two Towers to Golden Flower. Do we really need another set-to involving zillions of zinging arrows?

Yeah, we do. Woo takes all the tropes – armadas, ant-like extras and yes, arrows – and showers them with fresh blood. The action is stylised to the nth degree, without caving to shopworn floaty-fu or sheeny pixel-perfectionism. It’s hyper and real.

Flaming long, too – albeit not as long as the original two-part, five-hour Chinese cut. Concertinaed into a relatively rangy 150 minutes, the story (rebel kingdoms unite against an aggressively ambitious Prime Minister, circa 208 AD) can’t help but seem like a skipping record at times.

Whether it’s the ruthlessness of the edit or a glitch in the script, the epic outweighs the intimate here. Save for a soft-centred epilogue, the starchy chemistry between Tony Leung’s viceroy and tactician Takeshi Kaneshiro means this isn’t a vintage workout for Woo’s male-friendship fetish.

But screw the bromance; Red Cliff is a monument to brawling, not bonding. It’s also a strapping ode to giant-scale filmmaking, its widescreen wonders staged by land (horseback battle, fortress siege, soccer match), by sea (a 1,000-strong fleet of ships on fire) and by air (the camera taking extended flight on the wings of a dove – sorry, pigeon – over the entire human chessboard). And the arrows? Part of a fiendishly sly fake-out devised to nick the enemy’s ammunition. Big and clever.


 

Verdict:

Woo aimed for “an Asian Troy”, but any similarities to Wolfgang Petersen’s schlockbuster are purely coincidental – this is a sweeping, stirring breath-snatcher that finds the director on his finest form since Face/Off. Even half-cut, it’s a whole lot of epic.

Film Details

User Reviews

    • phillh79

      Jun 12th 2009, 13:20

      5

      Its Epic!! But im basing my opinion on the full uncut version. It kept me immersed for nearly 5 hours, the fight scenes were smooth and almost believable and it brings in a few heart touching moments. The only thing that does let it down is the cartoon red blood thats so common in chinese films. If you are going to watch it try and get hold of a copy of the original and get yourself a comfy cushion and settle in for a good evenings entertainment.

      Alert a moderator

    • dergerse

      Oct 1st 2010, 21:07

      Its great portal. Nice design. My Mahjong and Hidden object games, great Farm games free, news Pet games for kids, awesome Salon games for girls, usa Babysitting games free, best Air traffic controller game trial, free Download games and new Roads of rome game cheats for Hospital Haste fans

      Alert a moderator

    • estar

      Oct 9th 2010, 5:16

      5

      Ugg boots (sometimes called uggs)[1] are uggs on sale unisex sheepskin boots, made of twin-faced sheepskin with fleece on the inside and with a tanned outer surface. Ugg boots often have a synthetic sole, ugg stiefel although this is not universal. Heights range from around the ankle to above the knee, they are available in a range of different colours ugg evera as both slip-on and lace-up varieties, and they are produced by a number of manufacturers. The natural insulative Ugg Fluff Flip Flop properties of sheepskin gives ugg bailey button triplet thermostatic properties to the boots: the thick fleecy fibers on the inner part of the boots allow ugg cardy boots air to circulate and keep the feet at body temperature.[2] This means that ugg boots can be worn without socks even in relatively cold weather.

      Alert a moderator

    • krister

      Oct 28th 2010, 4:49

      As louis vuitton loafers louis vuitton sandals Salsa has become more popular louis vuitton bikini so has the louis vuitton scarf need for the gucci t shirt dance wear that gucci boots for women is needed men gucci shoes when gucci womens shoes you dance. Shoes are louis vuitton shoes louis vuitton flats one of the most gucci shoes high tops important parts gucci scarf of dance wear for the gucci jeans dancer. Dance shoes gucci sunglasses differ cheap gucci shoes from regular in gucci mens loafers many ways. louis vuitton shirts First regular gucci shoes gucci outlet shoes are louis vuitton sunglasses designed louis vuitton slippers to look attractive gucci shoes for men as its first priority, louis vuitton jeans and then they are made to be as comfortable as possible. Of course, compromises have to be made. The most beautiful shoes are certainly not necessarily comfortable if not uncomfortable and they will not be made for high impact activities.

      Alert a moderator

    • seded

      Oct 29th 2010, 10:17

      hosting unlimited bandwidth server hosting buy web hosting shared web hosting hosting

      Alert a moderator

    • seded

      Oct 29th 2010, 10:18

      professional seo search engine optimization internet marketing Seo consultants Seo Singapore pay per click advertising

      Alert a moderator

    • cataclysmcdkey

      Dec 4th 2010, 6:14

      3

      cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm wow cd key wow cd key cataclysm collector's edition cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm buy wow cataclysm wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm cd key wow cd key cataclysm collector's edition cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm buy cataclysm key cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm buy cataclysm key wow cd key cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm cd key buy cataclysm cd key wow cataclysm key buy wow cataclysm

      Alert a moderator

    • tomic

      Dec 15th 2010, 7:06

      5

      mbt mbt shoes cheap discount mbt shoes reebok easy tone reebok easy tone shoes reebok shoes nfl jerseys ugg boots on sale ugg boots uk discount ugg boots new era caps wholesale wholesale new era caps uggs boots vibram five fingers Mbt Shoes ugg boots uk nfl jerseys nfl jerseys ugg uk skechers develops skechers develops reebok careers reebok careers mlb trade rumors mlb trade rumors Shape Ups Shoes Shape Ups Shoes GHDs wholesale ghd skechers shape ups new era caps wholesale abercrombie fitch wholesale wholesale new era caps nfl jerseys wholesale ugg boots uk shape ups shoes canada goose jackets Jordan shoes wholesale ghd hair straighteners wholesale new era caps wholesale discount ugg boots wholesale new era caps moncler jackets jordan shoes wholesale doudoune moncler nfl jerseys wholesale nfl jerseys replica handbags wholesale nfl jerseys sale cheap nfl jerseys nfl jerseys for sale authentic nfl jerseys

      Alert a moderator

    • sarahpaul

      Jan 27th 2011, 9:49

      watch no strings attached online watch the company men online watch the mechanic online watch the rite online watch the roommate online watch sanctum online watch cedar rapids online watch the eagle online watch gnomeo and juliet online watch just go with it online watch big mommas like father like son online watch I am number four online watch unknown online

      Alert a moderator

    • jordansshoes

      Feb 22nd 2011, 8:59

      Abundance is a life cheap nike jordan on sale style, a way of living your life. It isnt something jordan shoes eleven you buy now and then or pull down from the official nike jordan shoes cupboard, dust off and use once or twice, and then air jordans 1 return to the cupboard.Abundance is a philosophy; it appears in your air jordans six rings physiology, your value system, and carries its own jordan retro eights set of beliefs. You walk with it, sleep with it, bath with it, feel buy jordan elevens with it, and need to maintain and take care of it as well.Abundance doesnt always men orginialjordan retro elevens require money. Many people live with all that jordan retro elevens money can buy yet live empty inside. Abundance begins inside with some air jordan 13 main self-ingredients, like love, care, kindness and gentleness, thoughtfulness and jordan retro 14 compassion. Abundance is a state of being. It radiates air jordan 4 outward. It shines like the sun among the many moons in the nike jordans world.Being from the brightness of abundance doesnt allow the new air jordans darkness to appear or be in the path unless a choice to allow authentic nike air jordan shoes it to. The true state of abundance doesnt have men's air jordan on sale room for lies or games normally played. The jordan shoes clearance space is too full of abundance. This may be a challenge because we still need to jordan on sale free shipping shine for other to see. HYD

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 10th 2011, 5:38

      It's even harder to argue trazodone without prescription that such extensions can provide any new incentives trileptal no prescription to authors who are no longer alive trileptal without prescription the new extensions almost always only apply long after an author has died. Instead, the extensions stop works from entering the public domain, where the progress of science and the arts would be promoted by having the works freely distributed, performed, and reused in new works zithromax no prescription. Furthermore, the repeated extension of existing copyright terms means that the Constitution's "limited Times" could be effectively unlimited, as copyrights about to expire could continue to be extended in this manner zovirax 400 mg indefinitely. Hence, the plaintiffs conclude, retrospective extensions of copyright are unconstitutional.

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 10th 2011, 14:45

      Which is why I'm hoping for an outcome that supports the Google Library project. While a Betamax-style court ruling elavil online affirming that providing a full-text search engine for copyrighted books is fair use would be one such favorable outcome, and one that propecia 1 mg would set a useful precedent, a settlement based on such mutual understanding would be a lot less expensive for the Author's Guild and for Google, and I hope that the parties can come propecia no prescription to such a settlement. (I especially hope that the academic groups that were making threatening noises against Google in the preceding months simmer down as well. Academics should be in the best positions to understand the benefits of liberal fair-use rights for education propecia without prescription and research, and thus for creating the monographs that we write and that Google seeks to index.)

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:17

      Now the bill just has to clear the Senate prednisone 40mg to be sent to the President, who is expected suhagra 100mg to sign the bill into law if it is sent to him. According to a telephone tetracycline with out prescription interview with Troy Dow, the Senate does not plan to hold hearings for this bill, and is expected to vote on it this spring. Unless Senators hear objections from their constituents, it is likely that no further copyrights will expire into the public online purchase revia domain in the United States until at least 2019. Not only would this hurt the availability of free on-line effexor no prescription books and other free uses of literature, but it would also hinder the creation of new works from old material.

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:18

      I'm very excited about researching and developing online purchase sibutramine digital libraries at Penn. I'm also very grateful for the support of the whole Internet online purchase suhagra community in building up this resource. I hope that you'll visit this site often and check out the new and old books, and be involved in supporting it. I'd especially like to hear your feedback and suggestions cipro no prescription as this site evolves here at Penn. The United States Supreme diflucan no prescription Court has agreed to hear an appeal by Eric Elred prednisone 10mg and other public-domain advocates challenging the retrospective aspects of the 1998 Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act. (Here's more information on the case, from the plaintiffs.

      Alert a moderator

    • Sekondman

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:24

      Major developments zyrtec 10mg in these cases will be reported at this site; for day-to-day developments, or to collaborate ampicillin 500mg on the appeal, check the OpenLaw site at Harvard. If the judges do find in favor of the public domain, we will be very happy to list any newly freed books at this site. Welcome to the new home for the On-Line Books Page. This Web site, and its editor, have moved canadian cialis to the University of Pennsylvania's Digital Library. I'll be working here to research, plan, and develop digital library canadian levitra resources and technology, to benefit readers both at Penn and throughout the Internet.

      Alert a moderator

    • Sekondman

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:25

      A related case, Golan vs. Ashcroft, is also keppra with out prescription challenging the constitutionality of the 1994 GATT copyright keppra no prescription restorations, the only time Congress has actually removed materials from the public domain and put them back into copyright. Those restorations levitra uk have also made it extremely difficult to verify the copyright status of most works of foreign origin published between 1923 and 1964. The case is currently in district court, and the Supreme nexium no prescription Court's eventual ruling of the Eldred case plavix with out prescription will undoubtedly affect its outcome. The United States Supreme Court has agreed to hear an appeal by Eric Elred and other public-domain advocates challenging the retrospective aspects of the 1998 Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act. (Here's more information on the case, from the plaintiffs.)

      Alert a moderator