Reviews

Room 237

4

Hidden meanings and conspiracy theories behind The Shining

We love escapism in movies, but what happens when a film’s mysteries prove so magnetic that we can’t escape them?

All kinds of merriment and mad readings, according to Rodney Ascher’s hilarious, head-spinning docu-study of one such movie-as-maze.

From five fans’ theories about The Shining, Ascher has combined an affectionate parody of obsession with a tribute to the ambiguities of Stanley Kubrick’s hotel horror.

The range of thinkers presented proves the reach of Kubrick’s Stephen King makeover. Ascher could have fielded bored stoners or jargon-packing academics in a mash of Clerks’ Star Wars debates and a film-studies seminar.

Instead, his contributors are foreign correspondent Bill Blakemore, history professor Geoffrey Cocks, playwright Juli Kearns, ‘culture-jammer’ John Fell Ryan and ‘hermetic scholar’ Jay Weidner, lively minds brimming with notions.

Granted, some of the notions stretch credulity: good luck spotting Kubrick’s face in the sky or – an old chestnut, this – penises in piles of paper.

The argument that Kubrick was mounting a confessional about his involvement in a moon landings conspiracy takes no less swallowing, though at least it furnishes some teasing observations.

The combination of keen scrutiny and Kubrick’s reputation provides traction elsewhere. Visual evidence is gathered to claim that Kubrick had bigger histories of violence in mind than Jack Torrance going loco; the Native American genocide and the Holocaust are touchstones for two believers.

You might think baking soda a flimsy basis for such ideas, but Kubrick’s fastidiousness and secrecy lend weight to fans’ convictions that the Overlook harbours hidden meanings.

Some ideas might rest on continuity gaffes (the vanishing dwarf, say) but the insights into impossible windows and creepy carpets prove too fascinating to dismiss. And too much fun, not least because Ascher makes up for his faintly overextended stay in hotel Kubrick with a visual flair that sucks you in.

He interweaves clips from Kubrick’s and others’ films energetically, veering between ticklish snippets of Stephen King in Creepshow and proof that The Shining plays well backwards.

Shots of someone opening a delivery of Kubrick Blu-rays sound more prosaic on paper, but time spent in Room 237 persuades us that they’re opening more than consumer gotta-haves: they’re opening treasure troves of intrigue to play in forever… and ever…

Verdict:

Meanings or myths? Rodney Ascher’s hugely enjoyable docu-collage of Shining theories embraces ambiguity but proves that Kubrick’s deep chiller is worth the revisits. Check in: eyes wide open.

Film Details

User Reviews

    • ChrisRoberts

      Jan 19th 2013, 0:51

      A Monolithic Hotel, One Room “The Shining” The Overlook Hotel. What Stanley Kubrick filmed in evil “Room 237.” The Apollo Moon Landing, cut. A white pioneer killing an Indian, cut. A Holocaust “shower,” cut. What the director of “237″ missed. Scene: Lobby. The African American Chef metaphorically lynched via a fire axe. “The Burning” never happened, because it didn’t need to. Stephen King got it wrong. Roll credits... "Hotel Kubrick: A Symbolic Odyssey." Chris Roberts

      Alert a moderator

Most Popular