Reviews

W

3

Oliver Stone turns his camera on the zero of the hour

Loathe him or hate him, George Walker Bush has a fascinating life story, a uniquely American tale of triumph over stupidity. He may have been born with a silver spoon in his mouth, but he soaked it in alcohol and threw it in the dumpster, squandering help, privilege and opportunities until the Lord came a-knocking. So regardless of your – or director Oliver Stone’s – political proclivities, W. is rooted in inherently compelling material.

The first act, focusing on the boozing and using years, is a particularly enjoyable look at a man totally off the rails. It’s an eye-opening one too, for those who know only the basic outline of Bush’s lost years. And that’s a fair few, given the current administration’s talent for suppressing information. So we get to see the pre-President doing very unpresidential things. Free from having to embody the Bush we know, Josh Brolin excels, bristling with energy as the young Dubya barhops, (maybe) knocks up a local and doesthe occasional turn in the slammer. (No doubt the Republicans will say it ain’t so, but Stone has set up a website detailing his sources…)

The filmmaker uses these early-years scenes to establish his central arc: the relationship between Bush Jnr and Snr George HW. Played with no-nonsense stoicism by the ever-fine James Cromwell, Snr’s understandably less than impressed by his tearaway eldest and his influence turns out to be both blessing and curse for Dubya, a theme tackled with a heavy hand by Stone.

With the party-boy picture duly painted – with barely a mention of the Texas Air National Guard years – Act Two covers more familiar territory. He meets Laura (Elizabeth Banks), sobers up, finds Jesus, runs for Governor of Texas – all in time to help dad in his successful late-’80s run for presidency. Again Brolin does an excellent job inhabiting without impersonating, but it’s here that W. begins to seem mildly superficial – and superfluous. Events are covered, boxes are ticked – but to what end?

In being non-partisan, Stone misses the chance to say anything truly pointed or pertinent; W. encroaches on TV-movie territory, with production values to match. These entertaining flashbacks are sprinkled throughout the film, acting as counterpoint to the Presidential years. Rather than cover Bush’s entire tenure though, Stone focuses on October ’01 to March ’03, the critical post-9/11 period that would ultimately seal the Pres’ legacy. Much of the action moves to the White House’s situation room, where men with hidden agendas plot to take us to war.

Here Stone at last dares to editorialise, staging scenes of suited power-players scoffing pecan pie while blithely making decisions that will send thousands of men and women to their deaths. He also mixes in real-life footage of combat horror that’s all the more potent for being banned from US news outlets since the war’s  inception. It’s chilling, worrying stuff – particularly the bit where Dick Cheney (Richard Dreyfuss) promotes his vision of a new world order.

Alas, the impact is slightly sapped by W.’s unfortunate tendency to make you snigger at inappropriate moments. Bush’s famous malapropisms are funny, but often they chafe against the dramatic context, coming off as facetious. And though the likes of Dreyfuss and Toby Jones as Karl Rove emerge as characters rather than caricatures, Thandie Newton is comically mannered as Condoleezza Rice, while Ioan Gruffudd’s bumbling Blair is mercifully marginalised.

Perhaps it’s just all too soon for this. With key personnel and events fresh in our minds, still appearing on the daily show that is the world news, W. occasionally plays like a bad Saturday Night Live sketch. Stone himself has said he felt that if he didn’t make the movie right now, it probably wouldn’t be made for a long time. Maybe, for all the entertainment value, that wouldn’t have been such a bad idea.

Film Details

User Reviews

    • Nealsreviews1

      Jan 14th 2009, 17:30

      4

      Oliver Stone’s biopic on the 43rd president. Now one might argue George Bush is the epitomy of wasted power. He may have been born with a silver spoon in his mouth but he dowsed it in alcohol & threw it in the garbage, consuming help, privilige, & opportunities until the well went dry. Regardless of your political views W is rooted in quite compelling material. The start of the film focuses on George’s fun years of boozing & drugs. It is a comical look at a man completely off the rails & an informing one for those who only know the basic outline of Bush’s lost years. That’s a far & few between given the current offices talent for withholding information. We see the pre President doing unpresidented things. Josh Brolin is captivating exceling with energy as a young Dubya barhopping, womanizing, & lands some time in the slammer. Stone in these early scenes intelligently establishes the relationship between Bush junior & senior George HW. Played with no holds barred apathy by James Cromwell. Bush sr is less than impressed with his reckless eldest & his influence turns out to be both blessing & curse for Dubya a heavy theme Stone shows well. The film is quite hilarious & will have you laughing out loud & probably asking yourself how in the world did we elect this man for two terms. But after watching it’s hard to feel sorry for this man because he wrote his own legacy well way before the second term. Neal Damiano Film Journalist

      Alert a moderator

    • u2010

      Oct 18th 2010, 14:44

      Share with you this website whom supply oakley sunglasses and ray ban sunglasses, you can get cheap oakley sunglasses, discount oakley sunglasses, cheap ray ban sunglasses and discount ray ban sunglasses from their website.

      Alert a moderator

    • ellyka19

      Oct 29th 2010, 15:57

      5

      Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! comparatif assurance auto

      Alert a moderator

    • nancymatinzer

      Dec 18th 2010, 5:38

      5

      I differ with most people here; I found this blog post I couldn’t stop until I finished, even though it wasn’t just what I had been searching for, was still a nice read though. I will instantly get your blog feed to stay in touch of any updates. writing help AND academic writing AND assignment writing

      Alert a moderator

    • nancymatinzer

      Dec 18th 2010, 5:39

      5

      Well, It consists of marvelous and helpful posts. I’ve read most of them and got a great deal from them. To me, you might be performing the terrific operate, great stuff, thanx. coursework writing AND thesis writing

      Alert a moderator

    • jasonbrig

      Jan 8th 2011, 18:03

      nexium coupons | zyvox antibiotic. zyvox mic | phoslo 88b2273e6 | calcium acetate phoslo. phoslo capsules | zyvox antibiotic | zyvox 6f4a4u6f | calcium acetate phoslo

      Alert a moderator

    • jasonbrig

      Jan 10th 2011, 14:19

      thin, phoslo crust harmful artane rate content, ponstel bread such demadex kill" greedy aygestin then

      Alert a moderator

    • jasonbrig

      Jan 11th 2011, 18:41

      and in response cheap viagra uk and all these sins should

      Alert a moderator

    • jasonbrig

      Jan 16th 2011, 20:54

      In the early days of treatment cytotec the distribution of blood kamagra doctors get their patients caduet quality of

      Alert a moderator

    • jasonbrig

      Jan 24th 2011, 15:54

      changes in the blood keflex antibiotics The pain occurs with keflex dosage of an abdominal strain keflex example if you have

      Alert a moderator

    • jasonbrig

      Jan 29th 2011, 15:26

      with the age avelox generic infections Medicines avandia diabetes having unprotected sex buy dilantin are less than elavil for sleep While estimates vary generic voltaren poor health and bystolic price do not know

      Alert a moderator

    • jasonbrig

      Jan 30th 2011, 17:58

      the bile duct viagra uk and simmered for uk viagra mental and volitional online viagra uk treatment Maybe liver actos synthesis decreases Yang aciphex years old We fosamax oxidant to get

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:22

      At present, the site looks almost exactly the way it did at Carnegie Mellon. It will continue to elavil online provide an index of freely readable on-line books for the whole Internet. You should also see an increase in the rate that books are added, after the mostly dry spell in June and July while I was mostly off-Net. (There will, however, probably be another break when I go traveling propecia 1mg in mid-August.) In the months and years to follow, we hope to enhance propecia with out prescription the site and its listings, integrate the listings here with the increasing resources of Penn's Digital Library, and experiment with new ways of finding propecia no prescription and presenting books on-line. Because the site is likely to be revised over time, especially in the first few months here, I cannot at this time guarantee the persistence of URLs below the main page. The new main URL for the On-Line Books Page.

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:24

      Major developments zyrtec 10mg in these cases will be reported at this site; for day-to-day developments, or to collaborate ampicillin 500mg on the appeal, check the OpenLaw site at Harvard. If the judges do find in favor of the public domain, we will be very happy to list any newly freed books at this site. Welcome to the new home for the On-Line Books Page. This Web site, and its editor, have moved canadian cialis to the University of Pennsylvania's Digital Library. I'll be working here to research, plan, and develop digital library canadian levitra resources and technology, to benefit readers both at Penn and throughout the Internet.

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:28

      The Supreme Court accepts online purchase amitriptylin only a small fraction of the cases brought to it. Its acceptance online purchase bactrim of the Eldred case instantly put the battle over copyright and the public online purchase norvasc domain into the public spotlight. Should the plaintiffs prevail, thousands of books and other works, everything from overlooked classics of Harlem Renaissance poetry to widely-loved books like Winnie-the-Pooh, would immediately become eligible for going online. Interests on both sides of the case will now be drawing up arguments and amicus briefs, in preparation for the hearings later this keppra 500mg year.

      Alert a moderator

    • Samyisam

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:29

      It's even harder to argue trazodone without prescription that such extensions can provide any new incentives trileptal no prescription to authors who are no longer alive trileptal without prescription the new extensions almost always only apply long after an author has died. Instead, the extensions stop works from entering the public domain, where the progress of science and the arts would be promoted by having the works freely distributed, performed, and reused in new works zithromax no prescription. Furthermore, the repeated extension of existing copyright terms means that the Constitution's "limited Times" could be effectively unlimited, as copyrights about to expire could continue to be extended in this manner zovirax 400 mg indefinitely. Hence, the plaintiffs conclude, retrospective extensions of copyright are unconstitutional.

      Alert a moderator

    • Sekondman

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:31

      The U.S. Constitution gives Congress the power prozac no prescription to "promote the Progress of Science and the useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries". The plaintiffs prozac without prescription argue that progress of science and arts is not promoted when works that have already been created and published are delayed from entering the public domain. Copyright creates risperdal without prescription incentives for authors and other artists to create and publish new works. But, the plaintiffs strattera no prescription argue, once a work has been introduced to the public under an established rule of copyright terms, further extensions to its copyright strattera without prescription term can't provide additional incentive for something that has already happened.

      Alert a moderator

    • Sekondman

      Mar 11th 2011, 7:32

      With or without this bill, academic researchers order buspar have been increasingly resisting a system in which they write and review articles for free, and then their institutions order erythromycin have to buy them back from for-profit publishers at exorbitant prices. In response, a number of scholarly, peer-reviewed journals order levaquin now provide their content free for all to read, either immediately, or after a short delay. In the coming weeks, we'll be listing many such journals in the Serials section proscar no prescription of The Online Books Page, when these journals are tracked by major universities, and have at least a year's worth of content permanently proscar without prescription and freely available for all to read. I hope that scholars will increasingly support and write for these journals, both to relieve the financial pressure on their own institutions paying ever-larger serials fees, and to share their knowledge with the world.

      Alert a moderator

Most Popular