Reviews

The Lord Of The Rings: The Return Of The King - Special Extended Edition

5

So, that's it then. It's over. After this, there is no more. Well, unless you count the Super-Special Anniversary Collector's Tribute Edition With Bells On which will doubtless arrive next year. For now, though, you can finally enjoy the `trilogy' in its purest form. We say `trilogy', but just as JRR Tolkien insisted The Lord Of The Rings was one novel in three volumes, so this is really one film in three parts. One very, very looooong film: 11 hours, 48 minutes from stirring start to tear-jerking end.

Buy the Extended Editions Box Set and you've the makings of a perfect long geekend. The Fellowship Of The Ring - always the most effective stand-alone outing - serves as invigorating induction to Middle-earth, while The Two Towers no longer suffers from narrative inertia - it has found its beginning and end. And what an end: the majestic Return Of The King.

Still, the theatrical cut of Peter Jackson's finale ran to a bladder-bursting 3 hours 20 minutes. Even with the aid of the pause button, the added 48 minutes might seem to be literally, um, taking the piss. The undoubted highlight is Saruman's final bow, which gives Christopher Lee's wizard such an effective, grandstanding swansong you'll wonder why it was lopped off the first cut. Likewise the Mouth Of Sauron sequence, an eerily effective demonstration of the enemy's manipulative power. Otherwise, it's a mix of good to not bad, with the simpering, chaste romance between Eowyn and Faramir the only real reason not to buy a catheter. You can easily take loo breaks during their longing, lingering glances.

But there's no denying the power of the piece as Jackson finally unleashes the full force of the gathered storm, with hordes of dark minions spilling out of Mordor to clash with Aragorn's hastily assembled army. It's a classy conclusion to a copperbottomed classic.

DVD Extras:

Four discs, with the main feature split over the first two to ensure maximum viewing pleasure. Four commentaries jostle for your attention, too: Jackson and co-writers Fran Walsh and Philippa Boyens swap engaging and affectionate war stories, while the Design Team and Production tracks are packed with facts.If it's anecdotes and clowning you're after, head straight for the Cast chat. It's not just the big names talking here - there's enjoyable input from the likes of John Noble, who proves a charming opposite of his on-screen character, the mad steward of Gondor. Once again, though, the show is stolen by the double-act of Billy Boyd and Dominic Monaghan. Elsewhere, the excellent Making Of docs allow the actors to reminisce and chuckle one last time. The fun continues with Cameras In Middle-Earth, packed with shots of the cast at work and play, while completists will head for The Unused Concept, a storyboard/animatic sequence that details a clash between Aragorn and a reconstituted Sauron.The star-docking downside is that, inevitably, we've seen chunks of this before. The effects featurettes are full of detail, but there isn't much that hasn't already been exhaustively accounted for. The Collector's Box Set includes a fifth disc on composer Howard Shore and a sculpture of Minas Tirith. A little too precious to be healthy, but this is still the franchise to rule them all.

Try This...

Leave a comment or submit your review and rating

Most Popular

  • News

    1. Reviews

      1. Features

        1. Video

          Close

          Log In to Total Film

          Forgotten your password?

          Close

          Join Total Film

          Registration is quick and easy

          Hint: Star of Fight Club, Se7en, Benjamin Button and Ocean's Eleven

          As you are registering with Total Film, we would like to think that you'd enjoy receiving the following emails. If you'd rather not receive them, please untick the boxes:

          * Mandatory fields